Trencher or mini excavator for a drainage project?

A 6 in slot to 36 in deep, or a bucket that digs any width and handles roots and rock.

Trencher or mini excavator?

The short version: a trencher makes one kind of trench very well, and an excavator makes any kind of trench. The trencher's chain cuts a 6 in slot to a set depth as you walk it backward, so the trench is uniform and the lawn beside it stays mostly intact. The excavator digs a bucket at a time, so the width is whatever bucket you choose, the depth is whatever the arm reaches, and a root or a rock is just another scoop. The trencher is faster and cleaner inside its limits. Outside them it stalls.

Cut. Straight. Narrow.

Best starting point for a straight run of pipe or wire in clean soil.

See the trencher

  • 6 in wide slot, up to 36 in deep
  • 35.8 in wide, passes most 36 in gates
  • Spoil lands in a row beside the cut

Dig. Any width. Any obstacle.

Best starting point when the trench is wide, deep, or in ground with roots and rock.

Explore excavators

  • Bucket widths from 8 in on the E10 to 24 in on the E35
  • E10 digs about 6 ft, E35 about 10 ft
  • Places spoil where you want it, including a trailer

What are you trying to do?

Choose your drainage task to see where to start.

French drain in a lawn

Trencher, if 6 in is wide enough

Most residential French drains are a straight or gently angled run from a wet spot to an outlet, in lawn, at a depth under 36 in. That is exactly the trencher's job. It cuts to a consistent depth and leaves a slot you can bed, pipe and backfill without disturbing the lawn on either side.

Check the pipe maker's spec. If the pipe plus the stone around it fits in 6 in, book the trencher. If the spec wants a wider stone envelope, or the route crosses tree roots, fieldstone or old footings, the E10 with its 8 in bucket or the E35 with a 12 in bucket digs it. The E35 also makes the spoil problem easier on a long run because it can load straight into a trailer.

  • Width over 6 in: excavator.
  • Depth over 36 in at the deepest point: excavator.
  • Roots, rock, buried concrete along the route: excavator.
  • A 36 in gate and an excavator-type trench: the E10 passes at 28 in retracted.
  • What width and depth does your pipe and stone spec call for?
  • What is the drop from the wet area to the outlet, and is the outlet legal to use?
  • Have you contacted MISS DIG 811 at least three business days ahead?
  • trencher
  • e10
  • e35

Downspout or sump discharge line

Trencher in the open, E10 along the house

A downspout line is shallow, narrow and usually short. The trencher handles the open-lawn part fast. The first few feet against the foundation and any turn around a corner are where the E10 earns its keep, because a trencher cannot start tight to a wall or turn a corner in the cut.

If one downspout runs straight out to a lawn emitter, the trencher does nearly all of it and a shovel does the rest at the wall. If a trunk line collects several downspouts along a wall, runs through a side yard under 36 in, or crosses foundation plantings, book the E10. It retracts to 28 in, digs an 8 in trench, and sets spoil out of the way.

  • Route runs tight along the foundation: E10.
  • Shrub and tree roots along the wall: E10.
  • Open straight run, one downspout: trencher plus a shovel at the wall.
  • Water already in the basement: that is a foundation question for a professional before any trench.
  • Where does the line discharge, and is that outlet lower than the downspout base?
  • What is the narrowest point in the side yard, including meters and AC units?
  • How many downspouts tie into one line?
  • trencher
  • e10

Water line to frost depth

A mini excavator, not the trencher

A potable water line has to sit below the frost line, which is about 42 in in most of southeast Michigan and is set by your local building department. The trencher stops at 36 in. That gap decides it: this is excavator work.

The E10 digs about 6 ft and gets through a doorway or 36 in gate retracted, so it handles a water line to a shed, a garage or a yard hydrant in a tight yard. The E35 digs about 10 ft with open access, places spoil cleanly and is the usual pick for a service line from the house to an outbuilding. The E48 adds reach and lift for heavier pipe and all-day truck loading; it does not dig meaningfully deeper than the E35.

  • Tight access: E10.
  • Long run with open access and a trailer to load: E35.
  • Heavier pipe, culvert, or a lot of spoil to load: E48 for reach and lift.
  • Anyone standing in the trench: slope or shore it. Listed dig depths are maximums at the pin.
  • What depth does your building department require for this line?
  • Does a plumber or inspector need to see the trench open before backfill?
  • How will spoil come out of the yard, and does the trench cross anything marked by MISS DIG?
  • e10
  • e35
  • e48

Irrigation, conduit or low-voltage wire

Trencher, almost every time

Irrigation pipe, electric conduit to a shed, invisible fence and landscape lighting wire all want a narrow shallow slot that closes back up without a scar on the lawn. That is the trencher's whole purpose. An excavator makes a trench many times wider than the wire needs and leaves far more to restore.

Set the trencher to the depth your electrician or the product calls for and walk the route. The tracks are easy on turf. For electric conduit, the depth is set by code and your inspector, so confirm it before you set the boom. The only time an excavator wins here is when the route is full of roots or rock, or where the same trench also has to carry something wider or deeper.

  • Route crosses a tree's root zone: expect to stall, or switch to the E10.
  • Conduit depth required by your inspector exceeds 36 in: excavator.
  • Dozens of short runs for sprinkler heads: still the trencher; plan the loop so you cut once.
  • What depth does your electrician or inspector require?
  • How long is the run end to end, and how many turns?
  • Has MISS DIG marked the yard, and have you located your own private lines?
  • trencher
  • e10

Clean a ditch or set a culvert

A mini excavator with a wide bucket

A ditch is not a trench. It is a wide shallow channel that has to be shaped and have its fall restored, and a culvert is a pipe large enough that nothing but a bucket places it. The trencher has no role here.

The E35 with the 24 in toothed bucket cleans and reshapes a roadside or driveway ditch and loads the muck into a trailer. The E48 adds reach and lift for setting culvert pipe and for reaching across a wider ditch from one bank. The E10 handles a small swale in a tight yard. Spoil from a ditch is wet and heavy; the 7x14 dump trailer reaches its weight limit long before it looks full.

  • Ditch or culvert in the road right-of-way: the road commission or township has to be involved first.
  • Culvert larger than a residential driveway pipe, or any work on a county drain: a contractor's job.
  • Wet, soft banks: tracks spread weight but do not make saturated ground workable; let it dry a day.
  • Is the ditch on your property or in the right-of-way?
  • How long is the culvert and how much does the pipe weigh?
  • Where will the spoil go, and can a trailer get to the ditch?
  • e35
  • e48

When a drainage job uses both

  • A long French drain with a wider collection trench near the wet area and a narrow outlet run across the lawn can use the E10 for the collection section and the trencher for the run. A water line to a new garage often pairs with electric conduit in the same direction: the excavator trench for the water, the trencher for the conduit at its own depth beside it. Both machines ride together on one delivery when the yard has the room, and a dual-machine load is priced at its own delivery tier, confirmed at checkout.
  • If you are unsure which one you need, the question to answer is the trench cross-section at its widest and deepest point. Six inches wide and 36 in deep or less, in clean soil, is the trencher. Anything larger, or anything with roots and rock, is an excavator.

Before choosing, check the site.

Measure the narrowest opening

Trencher 35.8 in, E10 28 in retracted and 43 in to work, E35 69.7 in, E48 72.8 in. Measure the clear opening with the gate fully open, including latches and the turn into it.

Check the travel route

Slopes, soft ground, septic fields, irrigation heads and buried lines between the drop point and the trench. Drainage jobs are on wet ground by definition; tracks help but do not make a saturated lawn workable.

Know the trench

Width at the widest point, depth at the deepest point, length, and what is in the ground along the route. That is the whole decision.

Machine widths, from our product pages

Width is the machine body. If you are a few inches short, pulling one fence panel is often easier than running the job on the wrong machine.

Bobcat E10 mini excavator — 28 in retracted / 43 in extended

Trencher 6 in x 36 in — 35.8 in

Bobcat E35 mini excavator — 69.7 in

Bobcat E48 mini excavator — 72.8 in

Before ground disturbance: — contact MISS DIG 811 at least three business days before digging or trenching. Free and required by Michigan law. It does not mark private lines.

Your trench checklist

Save these details before you request equipment.

  • Trench width and depth at the widest and deepest point
  • Run length and number of turns
  • What is in the ground along the route: roots, rock, old concrete
  • Narrowest access point and turning space
  • Where spoil goes
  • MISS DIG 811 ticket date
  • Delivery location and preferred dates

Let's match the machine to your job.

Tell us what you're working on. Our Hamburg team serves Southeast Michigan, seven days a week.

(810) 231-7368

Explore equipment for this guide

Questions before you rent

How deep and wide does the trencher cut?

Six inches wide and up to 36 in deep. The depth is adjustable, so you can run shallower for wire and deeper for drain pipe. The width is fixed. That makes it the right tool for drain tile, downspout lines, irrigation, electric conduit and invisible fence, and the wrong tool for a water line to frost depth, a footing, or anything that needs more than 6 in of room.

Why can't the trencher dig a water line?

Frost depth in most of southeast Michigan is about 42 in, and your building department sets the required burial depth for a potable water line. The trencher reaches 36 in. The E10 digs about 6 ft and the E35 about 10 ft, so either one gets there. Those figures are maximums at the bucket pin, and any trench a person stands in must be sloped or shored.

Which excavator bucket for a drainage trench?

Narrow buckets dig cleaner trenches and move less spoil; wide buckets move dirt and clean up faster. The first bucket is included: 8 or 15 in on the E10, 12 or 24 in toothed on the E35, 24 in toothed on the E48. Smooth buckets are available on the E35 and E48 for shaping a ditch. An additional bucket adds $30 for a day, $90 for a week or $270 for four weeks. Tell us the pipe and we will match the bucket.

Which of these fits through a 36 in gate?

The trencher at 35.8 in and the E10 at 28 in retracted can both pass a 36 in clear opening when the latch, posts and the turn into the opening allow it. The E10 then extends to 43 in to dig. The E35 needs a clear 6 ft and the E48 more than that. Measure the actual clear opening with the gate fully open, not the nominal gate size. Our backyard access guide covers the route checks.

How do I get them to the site?

The trencher rides on our 5x10 utility trailer with a 2 in ball. The E10 and E35 ride on the 16 ft equipment trailer with a 2 5/16 in ball; the E35 needs a 3/4-ton truck or larger, and the E48 is close to 10,000 lb so most customers take delivery. Delivery runs seven days a week on our trucks, priced by drive time from Hamburg: $85 round trip within 45 minutes for one trencher or excavator, $125 for a dual-machine load, and $125 or $200 respectively at 46 to 75 minutes. Beyond 75 minutes we quote by phone. The fee is confirmed at checkout.

How is rental time charged?

You pay for the time the machine is out, including weekends and holidays, not the hours on the meter, and run hours are unlimited. Periods run 1 to 4 hours, 4.5 to 24 hours, one week (which covers 3 to 7 days) and four weeks. Keep it longer than planned and the extra time is prorated, never more than the next full period. Fuel is billed at our cost.